Borderlands Movie Review: A Catastrophic Disappointment With A 7% Rotten Tomatoes Score

Eli Roth's Borderlands Fails To Impress Critics, Struggling to Capture The Magic Of The Beloved Video Game Franchise

The highly anticipated Borderlands movie, directed by Eli Roth and based on the popular video game series by Gearbox Software, has finally hit theaters, and the reviews are in. Unfortunately for Lionsgate and Roth, the film has been met with overwhelmingly negative reactions, earning an abysmal 7% score on Rotten Tomatoes. This is a catastrophic start for a movie that had high expectations, especially given the star-studded cast including Cate Blanchett, Kevin Hart, and Jamie Lee Curtis. So, what went wrong?

A Promising Concept, A Disappointing Execution

The Borderlands video game franchise is known for its chaotic, irreverent humor, vibrant world, and eclectic characters. Fans of the series had hoped that Roth, known for his unique horror style, would bring something new and exciting to the table. However, the early reviews suggest that the movie fails to capture the essence of what made the games so beloved.

Critics have not held back in their scathing reviews. The Hollywood Reporter described the film as a missed opportunity, stating that even longtime fans of the video game might struggle to find anything of value. The review noted, "At one point, Claptrap returns to operational mode after a heavy-weaponry assault and says, 'I blacked out. Did something important happen?' Not in this movie."

The Critical Consensus: A Flop Across the Board

The reviews across various platforms paint a grim picture of Borderlands. Empire's 2-star review calls the film "a botched Guardians wannabe," while Total Film echoes similar sentiments, lamenting the loss of the chaotic energy that defined the original games. The movie's disjointed narrative and lackluster execution seem to be common points of criticism.

IGN's harsh 3/10 review labels Borderlands as "a catastrophic disappointment," accusing the film of betraying the very elements that made the game franchise special. This sentiment is further supported by Digital Spy, which describes the movie as a "trudge through a noisy desert with some cosplayers," highlighting the disjointed and uninspired nature of the adaptation.

Gaming sites like GameSpot and Push Square were equally unimpressed, calling the movie "unremarkable" and "really bland." VG247 perhaps delivered the ultimate insult with a 1-star review, bluntly stating that "the Borderlands movie exists simply to exist."

What Went Wrong?

One of the primary criticisms across reviews is the movie’s inability to translate the chaotic, irreverent humor of the video game series onto the big screen. Roth, who is known for his expertise in horror rather than comedy or action, may have been the wrong choice to helm this project. IndieWire’s review suggests that the film's sanitization and lack of edginess reflect a misalignment between Roth's vision and the studio's expectations.

Moreover, the film’s narrative structure appears to have suffered from poor editing and an overemphasis on spectacle rather than character development or story. Many critics felt that the movie was more concerned with trying to be a blockbuster than staying true to the spirit of the source material.

The Impact on the Box Office

With a 7% score on Rotten Tomatoes, the Borderlands movie is poised to struggle at the box office. Initial projections of a $15 million opening weekend now seem overly optimistic. While the star power of actors like Blanchett and Hart might draw in some viewers, the overwhelmingly negative reviews are likely to deter the broader audience, including the game's fanbase, who might have been the movie's core supporters.

The Future of Video Game Adaptations

Borderlands joins a long list of video game adaptations that have failed to live up to expectations. While some recent adaptations like The Super Mario Bros. Movie have found success, others continue to struggle with translating interactive experiences into compelling films. This latest flop raises questions about the future of video game movies and what it will take to create an adaptation that resonates with both fans and critics alike.

Conclusion: A Missed Opportunity

In the end, Borderlands seems to have missed the mark by a wide margin. What could have been an outrageous, bombastic romp through a vibrant universe instead turned into a chaotic mess that left both fans and critics disappointed. Whether the movie will eventually find a niche audience or fade into obscurity remains to be seen, but for now, it stands as a cautionary tale in the world of video game adaptations.

Visit Dan Lalonde Films For All Technology And Entertainment News

Source: Comic Book Movie

Photo Credit: Lionsgate