Sony’s Spider-Man Spinoff Universe: The Final Bow Of An Ambitious Experiment

How A Promising Cinematic Universe Lost Its Way—And Why Sony’s Future Now Lies With Spider-Man Himself

Sony’s experiment with a shared Marvel universe featuring Spider-Man’s villains and allies may finally be drawing to a close. From the success of Venom to the flops of Morbius and Madame Web, the studio’s attempts to create a coherent universe without Spider-Man himself have struggled to capture audience interest.

The lackluster reception of Kraven the Hunter at Brazil’s Comic Con Experience (CCXP) is just the latest sign of the franchise’s fading appeal. But where did Sony’s Marvel Universe go wrong, and what’s next for the studio’s superhero ambitions?

A Universe Without Its Star Hero

Sony Pictures has long held the film rights to Spider-Man and many of his associated characters, thanks to a licensing deal with Marvel Comics that dates back to the 1990s. This allowed Sony to create the acclaimed Spider-Man films of the early 2000s, directed by Sam Raimi and starring Tobey Maguire, which helped define the modern superhero blockbuster. Even Andrew Garfield’s The Amazing Spider-Man series, though cut short after two films, demonstrated Sony’s potential to tell compelling stories within this universe.

The game-changer came in 2015 when Sony struck a deal with Disney’s Marvel Studios to incorporate Spider-Man, now played by Tom Holland, into the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This partnership led to major successes like Spider-Man: Homecoming and Spider-Man: No Way Home, with the latter grossing nearly $2 billion worldwide.

However, alongside these MCU successes, Sony pursued a separate strategy: building a universe centered on Spider-Man’s rogues gallery, but without Spider-Man himself. This led to films like Venom (2018), Morbius (2022), and Madame Web (2024). While Venom found success thanks to Tom Hardy’s performance and a mix of horror and comedy, subsequent efforts faltered, suffering from poor reviews, inconsistent tones, and diminishing box office returns.

The Rise and Fall of Sony’s Spinoffs

Sony’s spinoff universe began on a high note with Venom, which earned $856 million globally despite mixed critical reception. The sequel, Venom: Let There Be Carnage, fared reasonably well during the pandemic, grossing over $500 million. But the cracks in Sony’s strategy began to show with Morbius. Starring Jared Leto as the titular vampire antihero, the film suffered a steep 74% drop in its second weekend and became a social media punchline. Its $167 million global box office return fell far short of expectations.

The situation worsened with Madame Web, which opened to just $52 million worldwide, marking one of the weakest debuts for a major superhero film in recent memory. Critics and audiences alike were left baffled by the film’s direction, tone, and execution. The trend continued with Kraven the Hunter, which, despite its $110 million budget, played to rows of empty seats at CCXP—an ominous sign for its impending release.

Why Sony’s Marvel Universe Struggled

Several factors contributed to the decline of Sony’s Marvel spinoff universe:

1. Lack of Cohesion: Unlike the MCU, which maintains a unified vision and style, Sony’s films suffered from an identity crisis. Attempts to mix horror, action, and comedy often left audiences confused rather than engaged.

   
   

2. Absence of Spider-Man: The core appeal of characters like Venom, Morbius, and Kraven lies in their relationships with Spider-Man. Without the web-slinger to anchor these stories, the narratives felt incomplete and disconnected.

   
   

3. Quality Control Issues: While Venom succeeded largely on Tom Hardy’s charisma, later films lacked the same compelling performances or storytelling. The poor reception of Morbius and Madame Web highlighted a recurring issue with script quality and direction.

   
   

4. Audience Disinterest: Simply put, audiences weren’t interested in spinoffs that lacked the central figure of Spider-Man. The diminishing returns at the box office reflected this waning enthusiasm.

   
   

The Future of Sony’s Superhero Ambitions

Recognizing these challenges, Sony appears to be pivoting back to projects directly tied to Spider-Man. Upcoming films and series that leverage the character’s enduring popularity include:

• Spider-Man 4: Tom Holland is set to reprise his role in a highly anticipated fourth installment of the MCU-connected Spider-Man series.

  
  

• Beyond the Spider-Verse: The next entry in the critically acclaimed animated Spider-Verse series promises to continue the success of Into the Spider-Verse and Across the Spider-Verse.

  
  

• Spider-Noir: A planned television series featuring Nicolas Cage as the noir-inspired version of Spider-Man will tap into fan nostalgia and love for the character’s different interpretations.

  
  

These projects emphasize what audiences truly want: more Spider-Man. By leaning into the character’s central appeal rather than spinning off peripheral figures, Sony hopes to recapture the magic that made their earlier films successful.

Conclusion: A Lesson in Franchise Building

Sony’s attempt to create a Spider-Man universe without Spider-Man serves as a cautionary tale for Hollywood. Building a successful shared universe requires not only popular characters but also coherent storytelling, consistent quality, and a clear creative vision. As Sony shifts focus back to Spider-Man-centric projects, the future of their superhero films looks brighter. For now, the lesson is clear: sometimes, you can’t build a universe without its star.

Visit Dan Lalonde Films For All Technology And Entertainment News

Source: The Wrap Via Yahoo

Photo Credit: Sony